| Matchups | The Cool Pool | vs | Total Sports | ||||
| Greg Miller | Roy Andrews | ||||||
| Event Information: | American League | American League | |||||
| Event #14 | Will Riney | Chad Chacellor | |||||
| MLB All Star Game | American League | American League | |||||
| National League vs. | Adam Riney | Ron Cyphers | |||||
| American League | National League | American League | |||||
| Scott Polohonki | Shawn Jackson | ||||||
| Yankees Stadium | American League | American League | |||||
| New York, New York | Stephen DiCaprio | Cindy Riney | |||||
| Worth 7 Points | American League | National League | |||||
| Jeffery Willett | Frank Ward | ||||||
| American League | American League | ||||||